Movie Wave Home
Composed by
Rating
Album running time
Performed by
Lyrics
Engineered by
Released by
Artwork copyright (c) 2004 Walt Disney
Records; review copyright (c)
2004 James Southall
|
ALADDIN Wonderful
songs and score for colourful Disney adventure A review by JAMES SOUTHALL After the sumptuous Beauty and the Beast, Disney were
always going to be hard-pressed to come up with something quite so delightful,
and so it proved with Aladdin. It's a lovely film but feels
slightly flat only because it doesn't share the ambition of its immediate
predecessor. That said, it remains a colourful and entertaining film,
boosted by the humour provided by Robin Williams's character (which has been
imitated in virtually every Disney animation since, with ever-decreasing levels
of success). After his double Oscar win for Beauty and the Beast it
was no surprise to see composer Alan Menken and lyricist Howard Ashman assigned
to work on the film, but tragically Ashman died before the music was complete,
so Tim Rice stepped in. The contrast between Ashman's clever, witty lyrics
and Rice's more traditional words is clear, but each man brought a touch of
class, and Menken was on top form as well. Usually in situations like this
it's easy to pick out the "big song", but it's very difficult to say
any of the songs in Aladdin is less than exemplary. "One Jump
Ahead" is full of youthful spirit; "Friend Like Me" a real
Broadway-style show-stopper, and witty in the process; "Prince Ali" is
strident and dramatic; and the ballad "A Whole New World" really quite
delightful. Vocal performances are as fine as you might expect and
Williams is perfect. Of course there's a pop version of the main ballad, and Regina
Belle and Peabo Bryson's version of "A Whole New World" is less
offensive than these things usually are (but still not nearly so attractive as
the film version sung by Lea Salonga and Brad Kane). This reissued
soundtrack coinciding with the Special Edition version of the film on DVD
contains a treat for fans of Menken's work since there are two bonus tracks,
demos of songs which ultimately went unused, but are easily as good as what did
get used. "Proud of Your Boy" is a touching effort and
"High Adventure" quite brilliant and thrilling even in its unpolished form
here. (If nothing else, Menken proves that if he hadn't been the
successful composer he is then he could easily have cut it as a Broadway
singer.) While it's difficult to argue with many of the Oscars awarded
to Menken for his songs, the ones he won for original scores are more debatable.
Aladdin won both (of course) and, while I certainly think there were
stronger scores that year, it is arguably the finest of Menken's efforts in that
regard. It's true that it can at times be a little Mickey Mousey, but the
composer did a good job of combining the romantic, comedic and dramatic elements
of the film into something which flows rather well. For the romance,
"The Kiss" is the highlight, with a truly exquisite violin solo
version of the "A Whole New World" theme, and then there's the
sweeping, swooning "Aladdin's World". The comedic elements are
perhaps best summed up by the cod Arabic stylings of some of the tracks and
(somewhat predictable) Mickey Mousing, such as "Marketplace".
The score really comes into its own in the more dramatic sequences which are
perhaps not as common as one would prefer, but are truly wonderful when they
arrive. "The Cave of Wonders" is a grand piece, very impressive,
and the highlight is arguably "The Battle", a terrific piece of action
music of which any film composer would have been proud. All in all it's a delightful album, highly recommended.
It's been a pity that Menken was absent from the scene entirely for so long, but
let's hope that before long he can recapture this kind of form (which may be
highly dependent on Disney recapturing this kind of form in the films
themselves) for he truly boosted these animations to even greater heights and
the two or three that will go down for decades to come as bona fide classics
will do so in no small part because of his contribution. Buy
this CD from amazon.com by clicking here! Tracks |