Movie Wave Home
Composed by
Rating
Album running time
Performed by
Orchestration
Engineered by Released by Album cover copyright (c) 2006 Touchstone Pictures; review copyright (c) 2006 James Southall |
ANNAPOLIS Somewhat
generic military score has its moments of quality A review by JAMES SOUTHALL If like me you had no idea that Annapolis is
the United States Navy training facility, then you probably (a) aren't American
and (b) don't form part of the target audience for this film (which I thought
might be a long-overdue biopic of the Norwegian pole-vaulting nun Anna Polis,
covering the period up to her much-publicised, tragic descent into alcoholism
and despair). Like movies about baseball, ones about US military training
facilities seem to have a rather restricted global appeal. Sadly for its
makers, Annapolis turned out to have a fairly restricted domestic appeal
as well, with the 1,325 voters at the Internet Movie Database awarding the film
an average rating of 2.9 out of 10 (firmly one of the lowest ratings ever
awarded by that site's visitors) and Roger Ebert called it "an exhausted
wheeze of bankrupt clichés and cardboard characters, the kind of film that has
no visible reason for existing." Specifically, those
bankrupt clichés seem to come from An Officer and a Gentleman and Rocky,
with most reviews saying the film is like a strange amalgamation of the
two. Yes, Rocky. A film set in a naval
academy which features boxing may not be the sort of thing to entice audiences
the world over, but at least it's the sort of thing that usually proves fertile
ground for composers. Composer Brian Tyler's career is still in its
infancy but he's already written fine scores for more than his share of turds,
so he even has some experience of it. But something just doesn't quite
click with Annapolis - perhaps it's for the obvious reason, but the
attempts at sincere grandstanding always come off as sounding a bit fake
really. The main theme is blatantly trying to be like James Horner's Glory,
but ends up sounding a bit more like one of Trevor Rabin or Randy Edelman's
"stirring" efforts. The score is certainly at its weakest
whenever Tyler is trying to ratchet up the emotion - it just doesn't quite come
off. It's still OK, and in fairness is probably better than Rabin and
Edelman's similar tunes, but from a composer who usually writes such interesting
music, it's disappointing to hear him "dumb down" like this. The score is at its best when the action music
comes, and there is a reasonable slice of it. There are two styles -
first, the instantly-identifiable, highly-impressive action style Tyler has
honed over a number of films (what's this - a young composer writing action
music which doesn't sound like anyone else's?) which appears in
"Showdown" and several times thereafter. Second, and less
successful, are the (fortunately, more sporadic) sections with drums and guitars
and synths added to the mix, which might appeal to the kids a bit more than it
appeals to a wizened old git like me. There are a few more lighthearted
sections too, which are quite nice ("Training Begins" in
particular). There's a pretty decent 35-minute album bursting to get out
of all this, but sadly at 65 minutes, the music just isn't interesting to
sustain itself. It seems to repetitive and sometimes too simplistic to
warrant an album of that length, but I suppose it's better for a CD to be too
long than too short (better still for it to be a good length, though). Buy
this CD from amazon.com by clicking here!
Tracks
|