Movie Wave Home
Reviews by Title | Reviews by Composer

Composed by
ELMER BERNSTEIN

Rating
****

Album running time
47:45

Tracks
1: Prologue (1:12)
2: Main Title (1:40)
3: Riverboat Capture (1:17)
4: Regrets (1:48)
5: The Wide Open (1:48)
6: Eulogy (1:52)
7: McBain (1:09)
8: Digging Again (1:18)
9: Nostalgia (:50)
10: Attack (4:43)
11: Words (3:19)
12: The Sign (1:24)
13: Comancheros (5:31)
14: Hanging Around (1:36)
15: Keep Your Distance (:49)
16: Campfire Dance (1:59)
17: Tobe's Death (:58)
18: Leaving (3:46)
19: Texas Rangers (3:20)
20: Finale and End Title (1:10)
21: The Comancheros Claude King (2:00)
22: You Walked Away Claude King (2:27)
23: Main Title (mono) (1:40)

Performed by
UNKNOWN ORCHESTRA
conducted by
ELMER BERNSTEIN

Produced by
NICK REDMAN

Released by
FILM SCORE MONTHLY
Serial number
FSM Vol 2 No 6

Artwork copyright (c) 1961 Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation; review copyright (c) 2002 James Southall


Visit Amazon.com, the world's biggest soundtrack store!

THE COMANCHEROS

The Magnificent Elmer Rides Again
A review by JAMES SOUTHALL

The western was around long before The Magnificent Seven; but it's almost impossible nowadays to think of a western without also thinking of Elmer Bernstein-style music. He basically took Aaron Copland's famous Americana and made it even more expansive and expressive - absolutely perfect for the movies in question. Bernstein will always be remembered for the John Wayne pictures he scored, and The Comancheros was the first, made just one year after the groundbreaking film and score combination of The Magnificent Seven.

The theme is pure Bernstein magic: an expansive, folksy melody over those famous bouncy rhythms conjures up just the right images. "Attack" is a thrilling action cue, with percussive music for the Indians, finally with the main theme bursting out in particularly heroic fashion. The score presents numerous classic western scoring moments; in many ways, this score is the equal of The Magnificent Seven - and I think I agree with Elmer Bernstein himself that this main theme is even better than that earlier, more famous one.

Sound quality throughout is impressive - in stereo, I'm pleased to report - and, as usual, we get two a little bonus material: a mono version of the main title (for no discernible reason), and the two worst songs ever heard. Nick Redman's notes are mostly as good as ever, though I'm not quite sure I agree that The Comancheros "is infinitely better than almost any movie made today". But really, it's the sort of album whose very concept - Elmer Bernstein score for John Wayne western - renders any review unnecessary.