Movie Wave Home
Composed by
Rating
Album running time
Performed by
Orchestration
Engineered by Released by Artwork copyright (c) 2005 Disney / Walden; review copyright (c) 2005 James Southall |
THE CHRONICLES OF NARNIA: THE LION, THE WITCH AND
THE WARDROBE Disappointingly
generic score is a huge missed opportunity A review by JAMES SOUTHALL The thinly-veiled biblical allegories of CS Lewis's The Chronicles of
Narnia novels have always been wildly popular with children, and there have
been various attempts to turn them into tv series over the years, but
surprisingly, never a full-scale live-action movie before. But with the
astonishing success of The Lord of the Rings, it was only a matter of
time, and indeed 2005 has seen the release of the first of the adaptations, The
Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, with the next six presumably to come later
on. The choice of director - Andrew Adamson, who made the Shrek
movies - seemed a very strange one, and early indications are that it is
unlikely to be a success on the scale of Rings or, for that matter, Harry
Potter - but you never know. Adamson renewed his acquaintances with his Shrek composer Harry
Gregson-Williams for the movie. Gregson-Williams has been very busy of
late, seemingly leaving his Media Ventures shackles well and truly behind him
and emerging with a distinctive - and impressive - film music voice of his
own. It is disappointing, therefore, to listen to the first track of this
album and not be sure whether it might be music from Gladiator, Enemy
of the State, Spy Game, The Rock or Crimson Tide; one
thing it certainly doesn't sound like is "The Blitz, 1940", which is
what it's meant to evoke. But still. If the film itself is obviously
designed to look like The Lord of the Rings, it clearly isn't designed to
sound like it. "Evacuating London" which follows would sound at
home in an Ayanapa nightclub, with its chilled out pop beat and female vocal,
but it certainly doesn't sound at home in war-torn London. At this stage,
with five minutes of the album gone, one might be forgiven for thinking that
this was going to turn out to be the most disastrous film score ever written for
a major film, but fortunately things get a lot better (well, they couldn't
possibly get any worse) thereafter. "The Wardrobe" finally introduces the kind of beautiful scoring
which should have dominated from start to finish, with an arrestingly lovely
theme presented in deliberate, subtle orchestration. (Sadly, the theme -
the movie's main theme - sounds so incredibly similar to one of the secondary
themes from Star Trek: Insurrection, of all things, that I keep getting
distracted! I'm sure it's only a coincidence - and after a few bars it
branches off into something entirely unrelated - but it's still something I
can't help but think every time I hear the theme!) "A Narnia
Lullaby" introduces another device which could have felt like an
anachronism, an electric violin, but it works surprisingly well and is perfectly
effective and indeed pleasant in its countless appearances as the score
progresses. "The White Witch" introduces far darker material,
with the choir inevitably throwing its oar in as well, but it's decent
enough. Sadly "From Western Woods to Beaversdam" sees the return
of the wailing vocalist and pop beat but fortunately they're subtler here, and
therefore don't stick out as being quite so momentously awful, and indeed the
second half of the cue is really quite lovely. The gorgeous "Father Christmas" is a real winner, introducing some
real magic into the music for the first time, with the simple music box-like
accompaniment to some beautiful choral performances. "To Aslan's
Camp", which follows, remains blighted by the Media Ventures orchestration,
but at last is a larger-scale cue which begins to approach the scope of what
might have been expected of an epic story like this one. "The Stone
Table" is a lengthy piece which works well on an album, but which again
seems far too anachronistic for the film; but never mind, I'm reviewing the
album, not the music as heard in the film. With more samples and
percussion loops and vocals and the kitchen sink, it's a really well-constructed
piece of music. Much the same could be said about "The Battle",
which is a fine piece of action music for Media Ventures fans. Finally
comes the rather impressive finale, "Only the Beginning of the
Adventure", which along with "The Wardrobe" and "Father
Christmas", presents just about the only real bits of magical music in the
whole score, which is such a shame. After the score come four songs which
aren't that bad, though aren't especially memorable either, and Alanis
Morissette's hilarious mispronunciation of "Wunderkind" in her song of
the same name (which she even wrote) is perhaps the funniest thing I've heard
all year. I can't help but find The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe to be an
enormously disappointing score, despite it making a reasonably good album,
simply because it is such a mammoth missed opportunity. I'm sure
Gregson-Williams was only doing what the director wanted, but that being the
case it's a real shame that directors are so keen to get such generic music in
their films, especially given that the filmmakers so clearly admired every other
aspect of The Lord of the Rings and used it to such an extent for
inspiration. As I say, as an album it's fine, it just could have been so
much better. Along with the regular score album is a deluxe edition
featuring a bonus DVD with some behind-the-scenes stuff from the movie and
material about Gregson-Williams and the music; and there's an "inspired
by" album of Christian songs. Whatever floats your boat. Buy this CD from amazon.com by clicking here! Tracks
|