You’ve Got Mail

Wildly successful on its release, audiences couldn’t resist the reteaming of Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan, brought back together by Sleepless in Seattle director Nora Ephron for another romantic comedy. (And let us not forget Joe vs the Volcano. OK, perhaps let’s forget that one – but not its music!)

Speaking of music, You’ve Got Mail was the first of a few collaborations between Ephron and composer George Fenton. And it turned out to be one of the composer’s most popular scores – this is a genre of film that doesn’t tend to inspire the most substantial work from composers but Fenton wrote one of his most influential scores for it (for a period of many years afterwards, almost all romantic comedies would sound like this, rather than the saccharine strings-dominated sound which had generally accompanied them before).

George Fenton

It opens with its masterpiece of a main theme in “Butterflies in the Subway”. I can’t think of a better way of describing it than to say it sounds like the accompaniment to a Randy Newman song – not a specific one, more like all of them. The rolling piano, the gentle shuffle of the jazzy accompaniment – it’s difficult to avoid expecting that familiar voice to appear at any moment, whether to sing platitudes about characters in a Pixar film or, perhaps, some biting satire about social injustice.

Mike Lang’s brilliant piano playing perfectly brings out all the warm and fuzzy feeling that Fenton was intending to convey – it’s an insanely catchy piece of music, absolutely perfect for this film and indeed this genre of film, so it’s absolutely no surprise that it went on to be so influential.

There’s more to the score than just that, though – a more tender theme, usually heard on strings, recurs a few times; Fenton occasionally interpolates “Over the Rainbow” into it (and there’s even a vocal version featuring the incomparable dulcet tones of Harry Nilsson). And a traditional love theme with more swollen strings, which reaches its pinnacle in “Empty Store”, is a joy to behold. There’s a great set-piece, too – in “To the Mattresses” Fenton pays great homage to Nino Rota’s Godfather music (in particular the famous “A New Carpet”) – it’s genuinely funny music, executed so well.

I could sit here for hours and not be able to think of a single bad thing to say about this music. I imagine that everyone would struggle, even the people who find bad things to say about everything. It is so utterly charming, so tuneful, so delightful – perhaps it’s the greatest romantic comedy score of them all. The album passes by like a breeze and every time it finishes, I just want to start it again. Nobody would argue that it is one of George Fenton’s more substantial works – but goodness me, it’s nothing short of perfect for the film and it brings a smile to my face every time.

Buy from Amazon

Posted in

Reply