Latest reviews of new albums:
Passengers
  • Composed by Thomas Newman
  • Sony Classical / 2016 / 68m

Written by Jon Spaihts and directed by Morten Tyldum, Passengers is about a 120-year spaceship voyage where one passenger (Chris Pratt) wakes up 90 years early and, seeking company, then wakes up fellow passenger Jennifer Lawrence.  One thing leads to another and they find themselves in a variety of sticky situations.  The film was highly anticipated but has opened to lousy reviews.

This isn’t the type of film that would usually attract Thomas Newman, but I guess if he can do James Bond then anything’s fair game.  Spaihts says he wrote the script while listening to Newman’s music and I guess the composer fancied the opportunity of working on something different.  But if the film is not the sort of thing he would usually do, the music he wrote for it most certainly is.  I don’t think it’s possible to get more Thomas Newman than Passengers – if you put everything he’s ever done into a mixing bowl and baked it in the oven for an hour, when you fetched it out you’d get Passengers.

Thomas Newman

Thomas Newman

Offbeat rhythmic propulsion – check.  Pretty piano tunes – check.  Unorthodox instrumental solos – check.  World music flavours – check.  Electronic dreamscapes – check.  Big orchestral drama – check.  It’s all here.  Many people have compared the score with Wall-E which is understandable because that’s the closest he’s come in the past to science fiction, but really it’s like dozens of other scores too.  It’s the Thomas Newman equivalent of something like Bicentennial Man.

This is no bad thing, really – Newman’s a great composer and it’s always good to hear him just doing his thing.  The catchy rhythmic opening “The Starship Avalon” with its whistling synth effect gets you tapping your feet; the beautiful electronica of “Rate 2 Mechanic” is really quite wonderful; the frenzied buzz of “Precious Metals” (which reminds me in particular of his Best Exotic Marigold Hotel scores of all things, even with the Indian flavours) is really quite something.

I guess it’s the more overtly electronic music that stands out a bit – virtually the whole score has a lot of electronics in it but when Newman goes to town with it a bit, such as in the tense “Robot Questions”, it’s particularly effective.  In the following cue, “The Sleeping Girl”, the electronics continue but now the orchestra reaches its biggest proportions so far, strings swelling and horns blaring out in dramatic style, albeit briefly – and when it dies down again the emergent soundscape is just beautifully hypnotic, trance-like.

The first hint of a vintage Newman orchestral theme emerges in “Build a House and Live In It”, one of those trademark oboe solos floating in and out, How to Build an American Quilt-style.  It’s sumptuous.  And the dreamy “Spacewalk” – a perfect musical representation of weightlessness – and romantic, too.  This section of the album is my favourite – the first third or so is about mystery and anxiousness, then this middle section goes all light and melodic and wispy.

An urgency suddenly appears during “50% of Light Speed”, then things turn distinctly darker in “Cascade Failure” which actually turns into some pretty frantic action music, a rarity indeed for this composer.  (Unsurprisingly, it doesn’t last long.)  Things are pretty bleak in “Zero-Gravity”, the strings frantic, the horns unsettling, fast-paced electronic percussion keeping everything moving at a canter.  Then in “Looking for Wrong”, the dark drama reaches new heights, slightly abrasively perhaps but stirringly so.

As the end of the score approaches, “Chrysler Bldg.” offers a welcome return to a dreamier world, where the score comes closest to Wall-E‘s magical sound.  Then “Untethered” sees that wonderful floating feeling come back before things go south again at the start of “You Brought Me Back”, at five and a half minutes the album’s longest cue, but as its name suggests it does lead to happier feelings in the end.  The tender “Starlit” is a piano-led reprise of some material heard early in the score but this time with a much calmer, more reflective feel to it, and again it’s just gorgeous.  The end title, “Sugarcoat the Galaxy”, doesn’t offer a big sweeping resolution, but it’s a nice upbeat cue with lots of interesting textures weaving in and out of each other and a lovely chilled-out atmosphere.

Passengers really is the quintessential Newman score.  I guess what pulls it back from actually being one of his very best ones is that by having a little bit of everything, perhaps there is a sense that there is a lack of some real single identity to hold on to.  Melodies are there, great ones at times, but they are so fleeting – there are so many interesting textures – I love the electronic world which is crafted so carefully – yet the whole feels just a tiny bit less than the sum of its parts and at 68 minutes perhaps the album is longer than it really needs to be.  It’s smart music, no doubt, and no fan of Thomas Newman could fail to like it – add to that how beautiful it is at times and it’s an album that’s very easy to recommend.

Rating: ****

facebook.com/moviewave | twitter.com/MovieWaveDotNet | amazon.com

Deny the passenger, who wanna get on
Deny the passenger, who wanna get on
Deny the passenger, who wanna get on
Wanna get on
He wanna get on
Wanna get on
He wanna get on

Tags: ,

  1. Sullivan (Reply) on Wednesday 21 December, 2016 at 14:54

    Congratulations on reaching your 20 year milestone James. I have enjoyed your reviews throughout, in particular the ones in the past.

    By posting the Elton John lyrics in this review I believe you have reached “peak Southall” and should consider whether it can get any better. If not, consider retirement.

    Deny the passenger, who wanna get on
    Deny the passenger, who wanna get on
    Deny the passenger, who wanna get on
    Wanna get on
    He wanna get on
    Wanna get on
    He wanna get on

    • POJO (Reply) on Wednesday 15 February, 2017 at 23:32

      “…I have enjoyed your reviews throughout, in particular the ones in the past.”

      Outstanding!

  2. James Southall (Reply) on Wednesday 21 December, 2016 at 21:33

    Thanks, I think.

  3. Chris Gilmour (Reply) on Saturday 24 December, 2016 at 17:27

    Loved this soundtrack and saw the film today. Do you know if the track listing fits chronologically with the film? I wasn’t sure.

    • James Southall (Reply) on Saturday 24 December, 2016 at 17:54

      I don’t know… hopefully somebody can help. Newman’s albums usually don’t but there are exceptions.

  4. Mefisto (Reply) on Friday 30 December, 2016 at 02:38

    No, the tracklist isn’t in chronological order.

  5. ANDRÉ, Cape Town. (Reply) on Sunday 12 February, 2017 at 14:52

    You awarded NEWMAN’S score four stars James! I’m hoping his peers read your review, and honour his talent with an Oscar. He turns 62 years in March and, fourteen Nominations down the road, I’m hoping 2017 will be the year we all celebrate, along with Hollywood, his scoring achievements over the decades. FIMUCITÉ 6’s 2CD release [in 2015] pays homàge to Universal Pictures 100th Anniversary, by performing arrangements of scores from their Classic Film repetoire. Among the themes is THOMAS NEWMAN’S ‘Fried Green Tomatoes (at the Whistle Stop Cafe)’ – with DIEGO NAVARRO conducting the Tenerife Symphony Orchestra and accompanying the gloriously soulful voice of Esther Alfonso de Costa. It’s the first time I’m the theme, and that score is now on my ‘want’ list. Our JAMIE HORNER is represented four times, with suites from ‘Field of Dreams’…’An American Tail’…’A Beautiful Mind’ and ‘Meet Joe Black’. My JERRY GOLDSMITH’S Fanfare for Universal Pics was expanded into a 2’45” theme by Brian Tyler, while the closing sequence of JERRY’S ‘The Mummy’ includes his magnificent love theme arranged for Orchestra and Chorus. JOHN WILLIAMS, JAMES NEWTON HOWARD, ELMER BERNSTEIN, ALEX NORTH, ALFRED NEWMAN, JOHN BARRY, DAVE GRUSIN & DANNY ELFMAN are some of the Glitterati who worked for Universal and whose legacy is celebrated on this Album.

  6. ANDRÉ, Cape Town. (Reply) on Sunday 12 February, 2017 at 14:54

    You awarded NEWMAN’S score four stars James! I’m hoping his peers read your review, and honour his talent with an Oscar. He turns 62 years in March and, fourteen Nominations down the road, I’m hoping 2017 will be the year we all celebrate, along with Hollywood, his scoring achievements over the decades. FIMUCITÉ 6’s 2CD release [in 2015] pays homàge to Universal Pictures 100th Anniversary, by performing arrangements of scores from their Classic Film repetoire. Among the themes is THOMAS NEWMAN’S ‘Fried Green Tomatoes (at the Whistle Stop Cafe)’ – with DIEGO NAVARRO conducting the Tenerife Symphony Orchestra and accompanying the gloriously soulful voice of Esther Alfonso de Costa. It’s the first time I heard the theme, and that score is now on my ‘want’ list. Our JAMIE HORNER is represented four times, with suites from ‘Field of Dreams’…’An American Tail’…’A Beautiful Mind’ and ‘Meet Joe Black’. My JERRY GOLDSMITH’S Fanfare for Universal Pics was expanded into a 2’45” theme by Brian Tyler, while the closing sequence of JERRY’S ‘The Mummy’ includes his magnificent love theme arranged for Orchestra and Chorus. JOHN WILLIAMS, JAMES NEWTON HOWARD, ELMER BERNSTEIN, ALEX NORTH, ALFRED NEWMAN, JOHN BARRY, DAVE GRUSIN & DANNY ELFMAN are some of the Glitterati who worked for Universal and whose legacy is celebrated on this Album.

  7. Jules (Reply) on Tuesday 14 February, 2017 at 10:45

    As much as I’d love to see Newman win, it’s incredibly unlikely. The Academy favorite La La Land will obviously take the cake, no matter how superior other scores are. And if they haven’t given Newman a win for stuff of this caliber before, I doubt they will now.

    A major factor in the Academy’s choice is always the supposed quality of the film, and while I haven’t seen it, it hasn’t garnered much critical attention.

    I can think of fair few examples of a similar nature. See: most of James Horner’s catalogue.

    • tiago (Reply) on Wednesday 15 February, 2017 at 02:31

      Newman should’ve won his Oscar years ago, like in 1994, when, in my opinion, Shawshank should’ve won instead of The Lion King. Or in 1999, with American Beauty, or 2008, with Wall-E, both way better than the scores who actually won for Best Original Score on those years.

      However, I’m not so sure about this year. Yeah, Hurwitz will probably get the award, but, to be honest, I’m not much of a fan of none of the nominated scored this year. There was a bunch of other scores who should’ve been nominated instead of those five, like Fantastic Beasts, Nocturnal Animals, A Monster Calls…

      Although I’m a big Thomas Newman fan, and I absolutely love his work on the 90s/early 2000s, for me it’s clear that Passengers took the place that should’ve gone to Korzeniowski because Sony invested a lot on marketing for this movie.

      • Jules (Reply) on Wednesday 15 February, 2017 at 08:32

        Is The Monster Calls a good listen? I completely forgot about that one, it was on my watchlist a couple of months ago.

        I’m quite surprised Fantastic Beasts didn’t get a nomination. It was a lot better than Lion, Moonlight and La La Land. I think family films really missed out this year too – I loved lots of The Jungle Book, Kubo and the Two Strings and Pete’s Dragon.

        Even Newman’s Finding Dory. I enjoyed that more than any other score this year. ‘Shells’ gets me every time, and ‘Nobody’s Fine’ is fantastic.

        • tiago on Wednesday 15 February, 2017 at 13:42

          For me, A Monster Calls was one of the top five scores of 2016. It has Velázquez at his most emotional and touching, and, after The Orphanage and The Impossible, it’s clear that director J.A. Bayona brings out the best in him. Predictably, it wasn’t even considered as a strong competitor at the Academy Awards, but at least it won the Goya Award (the Oscar for the spanish movie industry, similar to the Cesar Awards in France and the BAFTA in England) for Best Original Score.

          I recommend you to take a listen at it. And I would love James to review it too here at Movie Wave.

      • Jules (Reply) on Wednesday 15 February, 2017 at 22:17

        Just listened to it, and I think it’s F.V.’s best score yet. Very sincere, and moving. Reminds me a lot of Alexandre Desplat’s more dramatic scores. ‘End Credits’, particularly, is just beautiful.

      • Edmund Meinerts (Reply) on Thursday 16 February, 2017 at 16:05

        You really think American Beauty is a better score than The Red Violin, Tiago? (Not just better, but “way better” too).

        • tiago on Friday 17 February, 2017 at 01:54

          @Edmund, my mistake, I thought it were Goldenthal’s Frida who bested American Beauty, but that happened three years later, with Road to Perdition. I guess this is what happens when you don’t double check your comments before you post them… 😀

          As for The Red Violin, I’ve never heard this score before, an error I will correct ASAP.

  8. POJO (Reply) on Wednesday 15 February, 2017 at 23:40

    I’ve been a huge fan of Thomas Newman’s work for years, but found this score to be incredibly jarring in the film. Maybe it’s because the film itself is a bit rubbish, but I can’t believe this score’s been nominated for an oscar. It’s down at the bottom of an extremely impressive list of work.